tvtropes.org

Bombing the Evil Away?

Our 'modern' world still is populated by archaic societies on various developmental stages. Two of them in the Near East continue to vex themselves and the rest of the world since decades. They are not the only ones, but actually enjoy once more exaggerated visibility, exceeding their moderate importance for this world by far (that could be a more comfortable place without them).
What happened? Once more, the one side exerted extreme aggression and cruelty towards the other. As a consequence, the other now takes revenge - we are tempted to say: as usual - by killing 10 times more civilian victims, corresponding to their personal view of their own higher 'value'. Their declared aim: to destroy the enemy for once and ever.
But can they reach this target? Careful scrutiny of outbreaks of violence during the last millenia leaves us with meagre hope. An enemy expecting eternal joys in paradise after a heroic death has an extra agenda beyond common reality. To split reality into two or more levels seems to be quite prevalent in societies on an early developmental stage.
It is fundamentally wrong to consider human societies as aggregates of biological entities. Societies are just the transient expression of collective behavioral traits maintained over many generations. At their core they have a narrative and more or less verbalized collections of dos and don'ts. A society can only be changed by adressing this core. Chopping off the blossoms will not kill the plant, but eventually even strengthen it.
The only efficient remedy against the eternal treadmill of violence and counter-violence is reason. Reason perceives and appreciates our one and only world as a fine place to share with our conspecifics. Reason accepts rules pertinent in the same way to all of us. Reason welcomes institutions and codes of conduct to regulate and relax interpersonal conflict. And reason ignores parallel realities of any kind in serious context (while encouraging them in private settings).
Neglecting the path of reason is easy. But ira furor brevis est. Fear and anger are bad advisors. More efficient ways to deal with aggressors are well known. It is a pity that most political leaders fail in their key obligation: to temper hot-blooded rascals and to pave the way to generally accepted solutions.
11/22 <          MB 11/23          > 5/24